Imagine driving through the heart of Southern Illinois, the landscape unfolding into a tapestry of rolling fields and charming small towns. As you approach Olney, you might be drawn in by tales of its unique inhabitants – the legendary white squirrels. But beyond these furry celebrities lies a hidden gem: a surprisingly vibrant food scene that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. Think small town Illinois doesn’t have culinary gems? Think again! Olney, Illinois, offers a diverse and delicious food scene, ranging from classic Midwestern comfort food to innovative takes on familiar favorites. This guide will explore some of the best restaurants and local flavors that Olney has to offer, proving that good eats are always worth the detour.
Classic Comfort Food and Local Delights
No visit to Olney is complete without experiencing the kind of hearty, home-style cooking that defines the Midwest. One place that embodies this tradition perfectly is The Lunch Basket, a local institution that has been serving up smiles and satisfying meals for generations. Stepping inside The Lunch Basket is like stepping back in time, a nostalgic experience that reminds you of simpler days.
The Lunch Basket
The Lunch Basket is a quintessential American diner, and the atmosphere is warm, friendly, and unpretentious. Expect booths upholstered in classic vinyl, the comforting aroma of freshly brewed coffee filling the air, and the murmur of conversations among regulars. This isn’t a place for fancy frills; it’s a place for good, honest food. If you find yourself in Olney Illinois dining, The Lunch Basket is a must try.
When it comes to must-try dishes, you can’t go wrong with their famous fried chicken. Crispy on the outside, juicy and tender on the inside, it’s the kind of fried chicken that makes you forget about everything else. Served with creamy mashed potatoes, gravy, and a side of green beans, it’s the ultimate comfort meal. For a taste of something truly unique, try their brain sandwich. While it might not be for the faint of heart, it’s a local delicacy that’s been a staple of the Olney food scene for years. Their homemade pies, available in a variety of seasonal flavors, are the perfect way to end your meal. A slice of apple or cherry pie is the perfect way to round out your Olney experience. Most meals are affordable here and the portions are plentiful.
The Lunch Basket is a local favorite because it represents more than just a restaurant; it’s a community hub. It’s where friends and neighbors gather to catch up, where families celebrate special occasions, and where visitors can experience the true spirit of Olney. It is one of the best places to eat in Olney and worth a stop for everyone who visits.
Joe’s Olney Grill
For another taste of authentic Olney dining, head over to Joe’s Olney Grill. This family-owned restaurant is known for its friendly service, generous portions, and a menu packed with classic American dishes.
Joe’s Olney Grill exudes a laid-back and welcoming vibe. The décor is simple and comfortable, creating a relaxed atmosphere where you can unwind and enjoy your meal. It’s the kind of place where you can come as you are and feel right at home.
The menu at Joe’s offers a wide variety of options, from juicy burgers and crispy fries to homemade soups and salads. Their claim to fame, however, is their incredible pork tenderloin sandwich. This massive sandwich features a perfectly breaded and fried pork tenderloin, served on a toasted bun with your choice of toppings. It’s a true Midwestern classic and a must-try for anyone visiting Olney. If you’re looking for something a little lighter, their homemade chicken salad sandwich is another excellent choice. And be sure to save room for dessert – their milkshakes and malts are the perfect way to cool down on a hot day. The great flavors and prices, make Joe’s Olney Grill one of the most popular restaurants in Olney, IL.
The Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Speaking of Midwestern classics, let’s talk about the pork tenderloin sandwich. This behemoth of a sandwich is a staple in many parts of the Midwest, and Olney is no exception. A large, breaded and fried pork cutlet is served on a bun, often with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles. The key to a great pork tenderloin is the quality of the pork, the crispiness of the breading, and the overall balance of flavors. You can find delicious versions of this iconic sandwich at various restaurants throughout Olney, but Joe’s Olney Grill is widely considered to serve one of the best.
Exploring Diverse Cuisines
While Olney is known for its classic American fare, the town also offers a surprisingly diverse range of culinary options. If you’re in the mood for something different, make sure to check out The Original Italian Pizza.
The Original Italian Pizza
This popular restaurant serves up authentic Italian dishes in a warm and inviting atmosphere. From classic pasta dishes to wood-fired pizzas, The Original Italian Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Italy in Olney. The restaurant is known for its family-friendly atmosphere, making it a great spot for a casual dinner with loved ones.
As the name suggests, pizza is the star of the show at The Original Italian Pizza. Their wood-fired pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in a traditional oven. For a classic choice, try their margherita pizza, topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomato sauce. If you’re feeling adventurous, opt for their specialty pizza, loaded with a variety of meats, cheeses, and vegetables. In addition to pizza, the restaurant also offers a selection of pasta dishes, salads, and appetizers. Their spaghetti and meatballs is a hearty and satisfying choice, while their Caesar salad is a refreshing and flavorful option. They have a wide array of amazing dishes, ensuring they are one of the best places to eat in Olney Illinois.
El Rancherito
Looking for something with a bit more zest? Then look no further than El Rancherito, a local favorite that serves up authentic Mexican cuisine in a vibrant and festive setting. Stepping into El Rancherito feels like entering a little piece of Mexico, with colorful decorations, lively music, and the irresistible aroma of sizzling fajitas. El Rancherito is a popular spot for both lunch and dinner, and its friendly atmosphere makes it a great place to gather with friends and family.
When it comes to must-try dishes at El Rancherito, you can’t go wrong with their fajitas. Served sizzling hot on a cast-iron skillet, these flavorful strips of meat are accompanied by a variety of toppings, including peppers, onions, guacamole, sour cream, and tortillas. Build your own fajitas to your liking, or try one of their specialty combinations. For a taste of something truly authentic, try their mole poblano, a complex and flavorful sauce made with chili peppers, chocolate, and spices. Their margaritas are another must-try, made with fresh lime juice and tequila. El Rancherito is a popular spot for locals and tourists, adding to the charm of the Olney Illinois dining options.
Sweet Treats and Coffee Shops
After a satisfying meal, why not indulge in a sweet treat? Olney offers a variety of options for satisfying your sweet tooth, from bakeries to ice cream shops.
The Uptown Bakery
For a taste of homemade goodness, head over to The Uptown Bakery. This charming bakery is known for its delicious cakes, pies, cookies, and other baked goods. The Uptown Bakery has a cozy and inviting atmosphere, making it a perfect place to relax and enjoy a sweet treat with a cup of coffee. They have a wonderful selection of desserts making them one of the best restaurants in Olney, IL.
The Uptown Bakery is a one-stop shop for all things sweet. Whether you’re looking for a birthday cake, a box of cookies, or a simple slice of pie, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your cravings. Their pies are a particular highlight, made with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection. The selection changes seasonally, so be sure to check out what’s on offer during your visit. In addition to baked goods, they also serve a variety of coffee drinks and other beverages.
Coffee Cottage
For a caffeine fix and a cozy atmosphere, check out Coffee Cottage. This local coffee shop is a favorite among residents, offering a wide variety of coffee drinks, teas, and pastries. Coffee Cottage is more than just a coffee shop; it’s a community gathering place. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot to relax with a book, catch up with friends, or simply enjoy a quiet moment to yourself.
Coffee Cottage offers a wide variety of coffee drinks, from classic cappuccinos and lattes to specialty creations. They also serve a selection of teas, smoothies, and other beverages. If you’re feeling hungry, they offer a variety of pastries, sandwiches, and salads.
Tips for Dining in Olney
Before you embark on your culinary adventure in Olney, here are a few things to keep in mind. Hours of operation for many of the smaller restaurants can vary, especially during slower seasons. It’s always a good idea to check their websites or call ahead to confirm their hours before you go.
In terms of pricing, most restaurants in Olney are moderately priced. You can expect to pay around ten to fifteen dollars for an entree at most establishments.
Olney hosts several food-related events throughout the year, including farmers’ markets and festivals. Check local listings to see if there are any events happening during your visit.
While some restaurants in Olney accept reservations, it’s generally not necessary, especially during off-peak hours. However, if you’re planning to dine with a large group, it’s always a good idea to call ahead and make a reservation.
Parking is generally easy to find in Olney, with ample street parking available throughout the downtown area.
Conclusion
As you can see, Olney’s food scene is far more diverse and exciting than you might expect from a small town. From classic Midwestern comfort food to innovative takes on familiar favorites, Olney offers something for everyone. So, the next time you find yourself traveling through Southern Illinois, be sure to make a detour to Olney and experience the delicious food scene for yourself. Explore the best restaurants in Olney and find your new favorite spot!
We invite you to experience the friendly atmosphere and delectable cuisine that Olney has to offer. Whether it’s the comforting aroma of fried chicken at The Lunch Basket, the sizzling fajitas at El Rancherito, or the sweet aroma from The Uptown Bakery, Olney’s food scene is ready to surprise and delight. So, come hungry and leave with a full heart (and stomach!). You’ll quickly discover that Olney, IL offers a memorable food experience for all.
