Coastal Casual: New Buffalo’s Everyday Delights
New Buffalo, Michigan: a charming lakeside town beckoning with sandy beaches, boutique shops, and, perhaps most alluringly, a surprisingly vibrant food scene. Just a short drive from Chicago, New Buffalo offers a perfect escape, and its culinary landscape is a delightful reason to visit. Forget your everyday chain restaurants; here, you’ll discover a tapestry of tastes, from casual eats to elegant dining, all woven together with fresh ingredients and a welcoming spirit. This article dives into the very best food in New Buffalo, ensuring you have a memorable culinary adventure on your next visit.
New Buffalo’s Casual Dining
The laid-back atmosphere of New Buffalo perfectly complements its casual dining options. Think relaxed patios, friendly service, and menus brimming with comforting favorites. If you’re looking for a spot to unwind after a day at the beach, or a quick bite before exploring the local shops, these are the places to start.
Redamak’s
Consider the delightful flavors at Redamak’s. A true New Buffalo institution, this family-owned burger joint is famous for its butter burgers. What’s a butter burger? It’s a simple yet sublime creation: a juicy patty topped with melted butter on a toasted bun. This isn’t fancy, but it is perfection. The no-frills atmosphere, friendly staff, and incredibly tasty burgers make it a consistently packed local favorite. Be prepared for a bit of a wait during peak season, but trust me, it’s worth it. With a focus on simple ingredients done incredibly well, Redamak’s is a must-visit for anyone seeking the taste of New Buffalo.
Bentwood Tavern
For a taste of the sea, make your way to Bentwood Tavern. Located inside a waterfront resort, Bentwood Tavern offers panoramic views of the harbor and a menu featuring fresh seafood and elevated pub fare. Imagine savoring a plate of perfectly fried perch, crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, while watching the boats glide by. In addition to their seafood offerings, Bentwood Tavern also serves up classic dishes like burgers, sandwiches, and salads, all prepared with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their outdoor patio is the ideal spot to enjoy a meal and soak up the New Buffalo ambiance, especially during sunset.
Brewster’s Italian Cafe
And for a delightful start to your day, or a leisurely lunch, stop by Brewster’s Italian Cafe. Known for its exceptional coffee, delectable pastries, and creative lunch options, Brewster’s is a local haven. Their freshly baked croissants, almond biscotti, and other treats are the perfect accompaniment to a steaming cup of coffee. For lunch, they offer a variety of sandwiches, salads, and soups, all made with high-quality ingredients. It’s a cozy and inviting space, perfect for catching up with friends, working remotely, or simply enjoying a moment of peace.
Elegant Evenings: Upscale Dining in New Buffalo
While New Buffalo exudes a casual charm, it also boasts a sophisticated dining scene. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, or simply craving a more refined culinary experience, these restaurants deliver with exquisite dishes, elegant ambiance, and impeccable service. These are spots to savor, linger, and create lasting memories.
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill
One prime example is The Stray Dog Bar & Grill. With its lively atmosphere and diverse menu, Stray Dog offers something for everyone. Situated near the beach, it’s an ideal spot to unwind after a day in the sun. From juicy burgers to fresh seafood, their menu caters to varied tastes. Plus, their extensive drink list ensures the perfect pairing for your meal. The ambiance is casual yet vibrant, making it a local favorite and a must-visit for tourists.
Marina Grand Resort
For an elegant dinner with waterfront views, consider Marina Grand Resort. The resort’s restaurant offers a menu that combines fresh seafood with classic American cuisine. Their dishes are expertly prepared and presented, reflecting a commitment to quality and taste. The atmosphere is refined yet relaxed, making it an ideal choice for special occasions or a romantic evening. Overlooking the harbor, the setting enhances the dining experience, providing a picturesque backdrop for memorable meals.
Gastronomy
And for a truly unique culinary experience, reserve a table at Gastronomy. With an innovative menu that changes seasonally, Gastronomy showcases the best of locally sourced ingredients. The chefs are passionate about creating dishes that are both visually stunning and incredibly flavorful. The dining room is intimate and elegant, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. Gastronomy offers a sophisticated dining experience that is sure to impress even the most discerning palate. With a focus on artistic presentation and refined flavors, Gastronomy is a standout in New Buffalo’s culinary scene.
Hidden Gems and Unique Food Experiences
Beyond the well-known restaurants, New Buffalo offers some hidden gems and unique food experiences that are worth seeking out. These are the places where you can discover something truly special, whether it’s a quirky food truck, a charming winery, or a market brimming with local delicacies.
Whistle Stop Grocery
Look no further than Whistle Stop Grocery for a unique and local dining experience. Here you can grab a pre-made dish, a deli sandwich, and a drink. You can either take it home or eat it on their beautiful outdoor seating. The food is fresh and the atmosphere is comfortable and inviting. Whistle Stop Grocery is the perfect location to get something to eat while on the go or if you’re just looking to get a quick meal away from the big crowds.
Round Barn Brewery & Public House
Consider also a visit to Round Barn Brewery & Public House. While primarily known for their handcrafted beers, Round Barn also offers a surprisingly delicious food menu. Their pub fare includes burgers, sandwiches, pizzas, and other tasty bites, all designed to pair perfectly with their beers. The atmosphere is lively and fun, making it a great spot to gather with friends and enjoy a casual meal. Their outdoor beer garden is especially popular during the warmer months. Round Barn provides a relaxed and enjoyable setting to savor local flavors and craft brews.
Local Pour
And for a taste of local flavors, visit Local Pour. This wine bar specializes in Michigan wines, and a curated selection of small plates and cheese boards to pair with them. It’s an elegant and relaxed atmosphere, and it offers something unique to New Buffalo. Its small bites and Michigan made wines make Local Pour a must-visit.
Sweet Endings: Dessert in New Buffalo
No culinary adventure is complete without indulging in something sweet. New Buffalo offers a delightful array of dessert spots, from classic ice cream parlors to artisanal bakeries. Whether you’re craving a scoop of creamy ice cream, a decadent pastry, or a box of homemade chocolates, you’ll find it here.
Oink’s Dutch Treat
For a classic ice cream experience, head to Oink’s Dutch Treat. This long-standing institution is known for its homemade ice cream, waffle cones, and friendly service. With a wide variety of flavors to choose from, there’s something for everyone. Oink’s is a New Buffalo staple, and a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.
Nancy’s Bakery
For decadent pastries, Nancy’s Bakery is the place to visit. Everything is delicious and they are well known throughout New Buffalo. It’s the perfect spot to grab a pastry on the go.
Seasonal Flavors: New Buffalo Year-Round
The food scene in New Buffalo evolves with the seasons. Summer brings outdoor dining, farmers markets, and an abundance of fresh produce. Fall offers harvest festivals, pumpkin spice everything, and comforting dishes. Winter brings cozy restaurants, holiday menus, and special events. No matter when you visit, you’ll find something to satisfy your appetite.
Final Bites: New Buffalo Awaits
New Buffalo’s culinary scene is a delightful surprise, offering a diverse range of flavors and experiences. From casual burger joints to elegant restaurants, from hidden gems to classic dessert spots, there’s something for every palate and every occasion. So, pack your bags, plan your visit, and prepare to discover the delicious side of New Buffalo. I highly recommend a buttery burger at Redamak’s – it’s a New Buffalo must-try! Come for the beaches, stay for the food. New Buffalo is waiting to tantalize your taste buds.
